Skip to content

The 36-to-1 Return: How Franklin County Small Businesses Can Build an Email Newsletter That Pays

Email marketing delivers measurable returns that few other small business tools can match. According to Litmus's 2025 State of Email Survey, email marketing outpaces most digital channels with an average ROI of $36 for every $1 spent. For businesses in the St. Clair area — where the chamber already connects you to local buyers, referrals, and community events — an email newsletter is one of the most direct ways to keep that network engaged year-round.

Your Social Audience Isn't the Same as Your Customer Base

If you're already active on Facebook or Instagram, it's reasonable to wonder whether a newsletter is really worth the effort. Your following is growing, you're getting engagement — isn't that enough?

A McKinsey & Co. study found that email marketing far outpaces social for acquisition, reaching 40 times more new customers than Facebook and Twitter combined. The deeper issue: your social audience lives on a platform you don't control. If an algorithm changes or a platform declines, those followers are gone. Your email list belongs to you.

Bottom line: Social media builds visibility; email builds an asset — the list stays yours regardless of what any platform decides to change.

How to Write a Newsletter People Actually Read

The mechanics aren't complicated. Here's a decision walkthrough based on where you're starting:

If you're starting from scratch: Set up a welcome email first. According to Campaign Monitor's 2025 guide, welcome emails achieve a 91.43% open rate — the highest of any email type. One well-crafted welcome message creates a strong first impression for every new subscriber automatically.

If you're building regular content: Lead with something useful — a seasonal tip, a local event worth knowing about, a quick how-to relevant to your customers. Promotion is fine; it just shouldn't be the whole email.

If you're unsure how often to send: Once a month is enough to start. Consistency beats frequency. Readers will open something they look forward to; they'll unsubscribe from something that feels like noise.

"Nobody Wants Another Email From a Business"

This assumption is worth examining directly. If you've held back on starting a newsletter because you didn't want to bother your customers, the logic feels respectful — but the data doesn't support it.

Research compiled by OptinMonster found that 80% of small businesses name email their most important online tool for customer retention, and 60% of consumers actually prefer to be contacted by brands through email. Your customers opted in because they want to hear from you. The newsletter is a service, not an interruption.

Start building your list now. Add a sign-up form to your website, collect emails at your next chamber event, or ask loyal customers to subscribe at checkout.

Automation Does the Heavy Lifting

Many business owners picture writing and sending something new every single week — and that's the image that keeps them from starting. That's not how effective email marketing actually works.

According to Omnisend's 2025 report, automated emails drove 37% of sales while making up only 2% of total email volume — a powerful efficiency advantage for businesses with limited staff. Email automation means pre-written emails that send automatically when a subscriber takes a specific action: joining your list, reaching a purchase milestone, or hitting a date trigger. You build the sequence once; it runs without you.

In practice: A welcome email plus a monthly newsletter template is a complete system — and both can be built in a single afternoon.

Making Your Newsletter Look Professional

Well-written content loses readers when the layout is hard to follow. Simple, clean designs consistently outperform cluttered multi-column ones.

Use visuals strategically. Photos from your storefront, recent community events, or your products make a newsletter feel specific — not like a mass blast. When sharing visual assets digitally, this is worth considering: Adobe Acrobat's free online JPG-to-PDF converter lets you transform image files into clean, shareable PDF documents from any browser without installing software. It's a practical way to ensure your attachments and flyers look polished on any device your readers use.

Stick to one column, a readable font size, and a single clear call to action per email.

Choosing the Right Newsletter Tool

Platform

Best for

Free tier

Mailchimp

First-time senders, basic automation

Yes (up to 500 contacts)

Constant Contact

Established businesses wanting templates and analytics

60-day trial

Campaign Monitor

Visual brand-focused businesses

No

Kit (formerly ConvertKit)

Content-driven service businesses

Yes (up to 10,000 subscribers)

Each platform handles list management, template design, and delivery reporting. Start with a free tier and upgrade when you outgrow it — migration between platforms is straightforward.

Bottom line: The right tool is the one you'll actually use; a free account on any major platform beats a paid account that sits idle.

Putting It Together for Your St. Clair Business

Email works because it's direct, owned, and measurable — three qualities that matter when you're growing on a real budget. The U.S. Small Business Administration, partnering with SCORE, offers dedicated small business email training covering list segmentation, subject line writing, and platform selection — a solid structured starting point if you want guidance beyond trial and error.

The St. Clair Area Chamber of Commerce's quarterly business meetings and community events like the Celebrate St. Clair Banquet are also natural places to grow your list and compare notes with other local owners building the same skills. Start with your existing customers, send them something useful once a month, and track what they open. That's the whole system.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a certain list size before a newsletter is worth sending?

No — a small, engaged list outperforms a large, uninterested one every time. Even 50 loyal local customers who opted in represent a genuine audience worth serving. Focus on quality sign-ups over chasing volume early on, and let the list grow naturally through chamber events, your website, and word of mouth.

A small engaged list beats a large uninterested one.

What should I actually write about if my business isn't naturally content-heavy?

Relevance to your specific customer is the only requirement — not industry expertise. A contractor can share a quick seasonal maintenance tip. A retailer can highlight a new product or an upcoming sale. Chamber members also have access to training luncheons and after-hours events that generate natural, timely newsletter content with minimal extra effort.

You already know things your customers want to learn — that's your content.

What's the difference between a newsletter and a promotional email?

A newsletter delivers regular, recurring content — news, tips, updates — that builds a relationship over time. A promotional email is built around a specific offer or call to action. Both are useful, and effective email programs mix them. The newsletter builds the trust that makes your promotions more likely to convert when you send them.

Newsletters build the relationship; promotions use it.

 

Scroll To Top